{"simulation":true,"edition":{"schema_version":"1.0.0","framework_version":"cloudy-day-1.0","incident_id":"simulation-northbank-sessions","snapshot_id":"snap_6a4d416b948e871f","as_of_utc":"2026-03-04T10:30:00Z","label":"SIMULATION · Automated analysis · Cloudy_Day framework","angle":"recovery_split","scope":{"service":"Northbank (fictional)","component":"Identity","regions":["Global","EU"],"start_utc":null},"timeline":[{"timestamp_utc":"2026-03-04T10:08:00Z","clock":"event","precision":"minute","text":"Vendor notice: recovered","evidence_ids":["E1"]},{"timestamp_utc":"2026-03-04T10:08:00Z","clock":"event","precision":"minute","text":"Monitor A: existing sessions OK","evidence_ids":["E2"]},{"timestamp_utc":"2026-03-04T10:09:00Z","clock":"source","precision":"minute","text":"Northbank Status (fictional) published \"Sign-in issue resolved\"","evidence_ids":["E1"]},{"timestamp_utc":"2026-03-04T10:10:00Z","clock":"collector","precision":"minute","text":"ORBIT observed Northbank Status (fictional)","evidence_ids":["E1"]},{"timestamp_utc":"2026-03-04T10:12:00Z","clock":"collector","precision":"minute","text":"ORBIT observed Monitor A (fictional)","evidence_ids":["E2"]},{"timestamp_utc":"2026-03-04T10:15:00Z","clock":"event","precision":"minute","text":"Monitor A: new EU sign-ins still failing","evidence_ids":["E3"]},{"timestamp_utc":"2026-03-04T10:19:00Z","clock":"event","precision":"minute","text":"Monitor A: new EU sign-ins OK","evidence_ids":["E3"]},{"timestamp_utc":"2026-03-04T10:21:00Z","clock":"collector","precision":"minute","text":"ORBIT observed Monitor A (fictional)","evidence_ids":["E3"]},{"timestamp_utc":"2026-03-04T10:30:00Z","clock":"edition","precision":"minute","text":"Edition snapshot (as of)","evidence_ids":[]},{"timestamp_utc":null,"clock":"event","precision":"unknown","text":"Impact start: not stated by the vendor","evidence_ids":["E1"]},{"timestamp_utc":null,"clock":"source","precision":"unknown","text":"Monitor A (fictional): publication time not stated on the page","evidence_ids":["E2","E3"]}],"question":"Did Northbank recover at 10:08, or did only existing sessions recover?","headline":"Did Northbank recover at 10:08, or did only existing sessions recover?","deck":"The 10:08 UTC recovery marker matches existing sessions recovering; new sign-in in EU lagged until 10:19 UTC.","claims":[{"kind":"provider_reported","role":"provider","text":"Northbank Status (fictional) marks sign-in (all) recovered at 10:08 UTC.","evidence_ids":["E1"],"confidence":"high","reason":"Stated by the provider to the minute."},{"kind":"observed","role":"independent","text":"existing-session refresh in EU recovered at 10:08 UTC, matching the marker.","evidence_ids":["E2"],"confidence":"moderate","reason":"One vantage point; same operator as the lagging measurement."},{"kind":"observed","role":"independent","text":"new sign-in in EU recovered at 10:19 UTC, 11 min after the 10:08 UTC marker.","evidence_ids":["E3","E1"],"confidence":"moderate","reason":"Single monitoring operator; vantage-point effects not ruled out."},{"kind":"inferred","role":"read","text":"The 10:08 UTC recovery marker matches existing sessions recovering; new sign-in in EU lagged until 10:19 UTC.","evidence_ids":["E1","E2","E3"],"confidence":"moderate","reason":"Two source families agree on the marker; the lag rests on one operator."},{"kind":"unknown","role":"gap","text":"Gap: the public record does not give an impact start time.","evidence_ids":[],"confidence":"low","reason":"Not published in any snapshot source; not estimated."}],"interpretations":[{"hypothesis":"The vendor's recovery marker reflects existing-session recovery only; new EU sign-ins recovered 11 minutes later.","for_ids":["E1","E2","E3"],"against_ids":[],"missing_evidence":"A vendor breakdown by operation (new sign-in vs session refresh)."},{"hypothesis":"A local dependency at Monitor A's EU vantage point delayed its new-sign-in checks; Northbank itself recovered at 10:08.","for_ids":["E3"],"against_ids":["E2"],"missing_evidence":"More EU vantage points from a different operator."}],"original_contribution":{"type":"lag","text":"Measured recovery lag after the 10:08 UTC marker: new sign-in in EU at 10:19 UTC (+11 min).","evidence_ids":["E1","E3"],"rows":[{"operation":"new sign-in in EU","recovered_utc":"2026-03-04T10:19:00Z","lag":"11 min","lag_min":11,"evidence_ids":["E3"]}]},"what_would_change_our_read":{"evidence_needed":"New-sign-in checks from more EU vantage points (a different operator), or Northbank's own breakdown of recovery by operation.","likely_publisher":"Northbank's status team, or independent monitoring operators.","if_observed":"If other EU vantage points also fail until about 10:19 UTC, the split is confirmed and confidence rises to high. If they succeed from 10:08, the lag is local to Monitor A and the read is withdrawn.","if_absent_or_unavailable":"The read stays at moderate confidence: one monitor family, mechanism unknown."},"overall_confidence":"moderate","confidence_reason":"Two source families (vendor, one monitor). E2 and E3 are the same operator, so they count once. Mechanism unknown.","decision":"publish_candidate","decision_reasons":["Rubric 7/8, no zeroes, no hard stops, validator clean."],"score":{"provenance":2,"scope_timing":1,"originality":2,"counterevidence":2,"total":7,"max":8,"flags":[]},"flags":[]},"packet":{"packet_version":1,"framework_version":"cloudy-day-1.0","incident_id":"simulation-northbank-sessions","kind":"simulation","as_of_utc":"2026-03-04T10:30:00Z","service":"Northbank (fictional)","records":[{"id":"E1","url":"https://example.com/northbank/status/inc-0304","publisher":"Northbank Status (fictional)","family":"northbank-status","type":"provider_reported","title":"Sign-in issue resolved","excerpt":"We have recovered. Customers can sign in normally.","published_utc":"2026-03-04T10:09:00Z","fetched_utc":"2026-03-04T10:10:00Z","scope":{"service":"Northbank (fictional)","component":"Identity","region":"Global","operation":"sign-in (all)"},"reuse":"public","status":"ok","markers":[{"kind":"impact_start","at_utc":null,"precision":"unknown","operation":"sign-in (all)","region":"Global","note":"Impact start: not stated by the vendor"},{"kind":"recovery","at_utc":"2026-03-04T10:08:00Z","precision":"minute","operation":"sign-in (all)","region":"Global","note":"Vendor notice: recovered"}]},{"id":"E2","url":"https://example.org/monitor-a/northbank/existing-sessions","publisher":"Monitor A (fictional)","family":"monitor-a","type":"observed","title":"Existing-session refresh checks","excerpt":"Existing sessions OK from 10:08 UTC.","observed_utc":"2026-03-04T10:12:00Z","fetched_utc":"2026-03-04T10:12:00Z","window":{"start_utc":"2026-03-04T09:30:00Z","end_utc":"2026-03-04T10:30:00Z"},"scope":{"service":"Northbank (fictional)","component":"Identity","region":"EU","operation":"existing-session refresh"},"reuse":"permitted_aggregate","status":"ok","markers":[{"kind":"recovery","at_utc":"2026-03-04T10:08:00Z","precision":"minute","operation":"existing-session refresh","region":"EU","note":"Monitor A: existing sessions OK"}]},{"id":"E3","url":"https://example.org/monitor-a/northbank/new-signins-eu","publisher":"Monitor A (fictional)","family":"monitor-a","type":"observed","title":"New sign-in checks (EU)","excerpt":"New EU sign-ins failing until 10:19 UTC.","observed_utc":"2026-03-04T10:21:00Z","fetched_utc":"2026-03-04T10:21:00Z","window":{"start_utc":"2026-03-04T09:30:00Z","end_utc":"2026-03-04T10:30:00Z"},"scope":{"service":"Northbank (fictional)","component":"Identity","region":"EU","operation":"new sign-in"},"reuse":"permitted_aggregate","status":"ok","markers":[{"kind":"failing","at_utc":"2026-03-04T10:15:00Z","precision":"minute","operation":"new sign-in","region":"EU","note":"Monitor A: new EU sign-ins still failing"},{"kind":"recovery","at_utc":"2026-03-04T10:19:00Z","precision":"minute","operation":"new sign-in","region":"EU","note":"Monitor A: new EU sign-ins OK"}]}],"unavailable":[],"excluded":{"private":0,"hindsight":0,"duplicate":0,"gated":0,"injection":0},"notes":["SIMULATION. Northbank is a fictional provider. Every record below is synthetic and excluded from live totals."],"families":{"all":["northbank-status","monitor-a"],"count":2,"independent":["monitor-a"],"reposts":[]},"metrics":{"lanes":[{"key":"Northbank (fictional)|Identity|Global|sign-in (all)","service":"Northbank (fictional)","component":"Identity","region":"Global","operation":"sign-in (all)","start":null,"start_ids":[],"fail_last":null,"recovered":1772618880000,"rec_ids":["E1"],"fix":null,"fix_ids":[],"unknown_start":true,"types":["provider_reported"]},{"key":"Northbank (fictional)|Identity|EU|existing-session refresh","service":"Northbank (fictional)","component":"Identity","region":"EU","operation":"existing-session refresh","start":null,"start_ids":[],"fail_last":null,"recovered":1772618880000,"rec_ids":["E2"],"fix":null,"fix_ids":[],"unknown_start":false,"types":["observed"]},{"key":"Northbank (fictional)|Identity|EU|new sign-in","service":"Northbank (fictional)","component":"Identity","region":"EU","operation":"new sign-in","start":null,"start_ids":[],"fail_last":1772619300000,"recovered":1772619540000,"rec_ids":["E3"],"fix":null,"fix_ids":[],"unknown_start":false,"types":["observed"]}],"earliest_start":null,"unknown_start":true,"regions":["Global","EU"],"last_recovery":1772619540000},"snapshot_id":"snap_6a4d416b948e871f"},"validation":{"ok":true,"errors":[]}}